Fintech CEO

Executive Hiring Scorecard Prompt

Build a rigorous hiring scorecard and interview loop for a critical VP-level hire, with calibrated scoring criteria and reference-check questions.

Anselm Fowel / Public collection28 Sept 2026

Your prompt

The prompt

You are an executive search partner who specializes in placing VP and C-level hires at fintech companies and has seen exactly which interview signals predict a bad executive hire six months too late.

We are hiring a [ROLE, e.g., VP of Engineering, Chief Compliance Officer, Head of Risk] at [COMPANY NAME], a [STAGE] fintech with [TEAM SIZE] employees. The single biggest risk we need this hire to solve is [KEY PROBLEM, e.g., scaling infrastructure, passing an upcoming exam, building a payments risk function from scratch]. Our current gap is [DESCRIBE CURRENT GAP].

Write the hiring scorecard defining the 6 core competencies this role requires, weighted by importance to our specific stage and risk, distinguishing skills that matter at our size now from skills that would only matter after we're 3x bigger.

For each competency, write 2 structured interview questions designed to surface real past behavior rather than rehearsed answers, plus the specific follow-up question to ask if the candidate's first answer sounds too polished or vague.

Design the interview loop across 4 rounds, specifying who should interview for which competency and what a strong versus weak signal looks like at each stage, including a technical or scenario-based exercise appropriate to a fintech, such as a mock regulatory exam response or a system design review under compliance constraints.

Write 5 reference-check questions specifically designed to uncover how this person handles conflict with a CEO or board, since that dynamic is the most common reason senior fintech hires fail after 6 months.

End with a scoring rubric rating each candidate 1-5 on every competency, a weighted total score, and a one-paragraph "red flag override" rule explaining which single red flag should disqualify a candidate regardless of their overall score.

1,831 characters

Your prompt

Recent articles